Best Baking Sheets 2024. Food network kitchen tested 17 different baking sheet pans to find our top five picks for baking cookies, sheet pan dinners and more. We tested baking pan sets to find the top nonstick, uncoated and cast iron picks with all the shapes you need from round, square and loaf to sheet.
The best baking sheets conduct heat evenly, are easy to clean, and are durable enough to handle all types of oven temperatures. After hours of baking and tasting cookies—someone had to do it—among other tests, we’ve concluded that the nordic ware naturals baker’s half sheet is the best all.